Kim Kardashian’s advice to women in business has received backlash

Kim Kardashian attends the 2019 E! People’s Choice Awards at Barker Hangar on November 10, 2019 in Santa Monica, California.

Rodin Eckenroth | WireImage | Getty Images

Kim Kardashian came under some heavy criticism this week after offering some eye-catching advice to women, with a career coach telling CNBC that her comments likely sent a “dangerous” message to her younger followers.

The Kardashians had this guidance for women in show business in Interview With Variety released on Wednesday: “Get your ass and work. Looks like no one wants to work these days.”

Unsurprisingly, it sparked a social media storm, with Twitter users criticizing Kardashian for her “deaf” comments.

Actress Jamila Jamil praised her in the comments, Twitter: “I think if you grew up in Beverly Hills with very successful parents in what used to be just a smaller mansion…no one needs to hear your thoughts on success/work ethic.”

Jamil added, “These same 24 hours in the day are a nightmare. 99.9% of the world’s population grew up with very different 24 hours.”

Twitter users were quick to draw comparisons between Kardashian’s advice and comments made by British “Love Island” star Molly May Haig in a podcast interview.

clip from Interview with The Hague in a CEO Diary podcast In December it reappeared a month later and quickly went viral. In the clip, the Briton doubled down on the argument that “Beyoncé has the same 24 hours a day that we do”.

“When I’ve talked about it before in the past, I’ve been criticized a little bit by saying ‘It’s easy for you to say… you struggle with big money, so for you to sit there and say we have the same 24 hours in a day,’ it’s not true,” Haig said. But technically what I’m saying is true, we do.”

See also  Kim Kardashian and Kanye West reconnect as co-parents

Haig, who finished second on popular reality TV show “Love Island,” was appointed creative director for clothing brand Pretty Little Thing in August and It is said that he charges six figures (in British pounds) a month in her role.

Meanwhile, Kardashian is said to have a net worth of $1.8 billion, according to Forbes magazine. Against the backdrop of the success of the reality TV show Keeping Up With the Kardashians, Kim and her family amassed their fortunes by creating an empire of retail brands.

In fact, the show’s very name is a twist on the message of the classic American dream “Keeping Up With the Neighbors.”

So it is understandable that people are looking to emulate this success. However, one career coach notes that both Kardashian and Hague’s comments can add to harmful social media messages about work ethic.

Toxic positivity.

Emma Harrison, a freelance career coach, told CNBC that both Haig and Kardashian “show an ignorance of the live experience of the 99% and that their messages pose a real danger to their followers, especially those who are younger and easily influenced.”

Harrison, a senior lecturer in careers, counseling and counseling at Canterbury Christchurch University in the UK, noted that there has been a rise in the number of influencers giving advice via social media, which has been closely linked to the messages of ‘toxic positivity’ already existing around these platforms. .

“This idea that a person’s mindset can change everything or that the only thing holding them back is toxic and unhelpful in the same way that Kim Kardashian and Molly Mae have used it.” [Hague] And countless other touching messages.”

CNBC has contacted publicists for Kim Kardashian Tracy Romulus, as well as Francesca Britton, Molly May Hague’s manager, and has yet to respond to a response.

‘Relevant and actionable’ advice

Kat Hutchings, a leadership and career coach who runs her own company, told CNBC that “looking at people at the peak of their careers/success or having [Instagram] Fame or celebrity status can create a feeling that we will never get there.”

Additionally, she said, it can also make people feel as though we “need to be someone other than ourselves in order to achieve” success.

Hutchings recommended looking for role models who advance in their careers by two to five years and remember what it was like when you were where you were: “Their advice is helpful, relevant, and actionable.”

She added that the people we admire in our careers should also remind us that “having a vision and ambition is important, but what’s most important is taking small steps every day toward what we want.”

Hutchings added that people should be “less distracted by the glamor of someone operating in a context very different from us and [be] Able to filter experiences and tips that help us move forward.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.